Publishing

The second list in every recipe: what it uses up besides food

A cook pulls plastic wrap from the roll over a glass dish of raw chicken, with a paper towel holder on the counter behind

Disclosure: Peristyle is an Amazon Associate and earns from qualifying purchases made through its household list. This post contains no tagged Amazon links.

Read a recipe slowly and you find a second shopping list inside the steps. It is not the ingredients, and it is not the equipment a reader buys once. It is the things the recipe uses up: the bag the chicken marinates in, the foil it rests under, the paper towel, the soap at the end. Readers run out of them between recipes, and most recipe cards never name them.

This post is about that list: where it hides, why it is worth writing down, and how to point readers to it without turning a recipe into a catalog.

One recipe, read for the second list

Toscano's Table, a site Peristyle built and runs, has a Grilled Greek Chicken with Garlic Rice and Greek Salad. The ingredient list is thorough, in four parts: the marinade and dressing, the garlic rice, the salad, the tzatziki. Now read the steps instead:

  • Step 2: "Trim the chicken and add to a ziplock bag." A gallon bag, to hold a pound of chicken and half the marinade.
  • Step 9: "Preheat the grill to medium-high heat and grease it." Plenty of cooks do that with an oiled paper towel held in tongs.
  • Step 11: "Remove from the grill, cover with foil, and let rest for 5 minutes." Foil.
  • After step 12: a rice pot, a salad bowl, and whatever the marinade was whisked in. Dish soap, or a dishwasher pod.

None of those is an ingredient, and none is equipment in the usual sense. Here is the interesting part: the recipe's equipment section already lists the gallon bags, right beside the meat thermometer and the grill pan, because the recipe does not work without one. That is the second list, caught in the act.

Why it is worth writing down

It is where a cook gets stuck. A missing ingredient shows up when the reader makes a grocery list, before they start. A missing gallon bag tends to show up with the chicken already trimmed and the marinade already whisked.

Specific words get repeated right. "A gallon zip-top bag" is more useful than "a bag," and "cover with foil" is more useful than "cover." A reader skimming on a phone, a shopping list app, and an assistant reading your recipe aloud can only carry forward what the step actually says. The more exact the step, the more exact the copy, and the more likely your name stays attached to a recipe that still works.

It is the honest place for a product recommendation. An equipment link asks a reader to buy something once, and it only earns trust if you actually own the thing. The second list is smaller and humbler. Most of it does not need a brand at all. When one item does matter to the result, saying which one and why is the most useful sentence on the page.

How to write it into a recipe

  1. Name the thing in the step where it is used, with its size or type. "A gallon zip-top bag," "heavy-duty foil," "parchment, not wax paper." The step is where the reader's hands are.
  2. Put the ones the recipe cannot work without in the equipment section, the way Toscano's Table does with the bag. Leave out what every kitchen has. Nobody needs dish soap on an equipment list.
  3. Only name a brand when it changes the result, and say how in one sentence. For example: "Heavy-duty foil. The regular kind tears when I tent anything straight off the grill." If you cannot write that sentence, the brand does not belong there.
  4. Do not link every noun. A reader who sees a link on everything stops trusting the links that matter.
  5. If a link goes to Amazon, follow Amazon's rules. Disclosure at the top of the post, no typed prices, no copied product photos, no links in the printable card, and rel="sponsored" on the link. Our Amazon rules post has the full list, quoted from the policy.

Where the two lists go

The two lists get bought in different places, so they should go to different places.

The ingredients go to the reader's local grocery store. Peristyle fills a real cart at Kroger or Walmart from the recipe in one tap, and every order is credited back to the creator who wrote it.

The second list gets restocked, not bought per recipe. Nobody buys foil for one chicken dinner. So we keep it separate: a household list of ten everyday picks, in kitchen order rather than ranked.

  • In the drawer: aluminum foil, plastic wrap, gallon storage bags.
  • At the sink: dish soap, dishwasher pods, paper towels, kitchen trash bags.
  • Around the house: paper napkins, laundry detergent, toilet paper.

It goes to an Amazon cart in one step. We show no prices and no Amazon images; Amazon shows the price on its own confirm page, and nothing goes in the cart until the shopper presses Add to Cart there. Those picks are tagged to Peristyle, not to a creator, and the page says so beside the button.

The checklist

  1. Read your steps, not your ingredients, and mark every word for something that gets used up.
  2. Give each one a size or a type.
  3. Move the ones the recipe cannot work without into the equipment section.
  4. Name a brand only when you can say, in one sentence, what it changes.
  5. Disclose at the top, keep links out of the print view, and mark them rel="sponsored".

It is an afternoon's work on your most-cooked recipes, and it is the kind of detail readers remember: the recipe that told them to get the bag out before they started.